The cycle and the first loan
BRRRR is a five-step cycle: buy a house below its finished value, rehab it, rent it, refinance into a long-term loan, and repeat with the cash the refinance returns. The long-term loan is usually a DSCR loan, short for debt service coverage ratio, which qualifies the property mainly on whether its rent covers its full monthly cost.
Through Think Off Market the first loan is handled before you start. Every listing is pre-approved by Think Private Lending for as much as 90% of the purchase price plus the full rehab budget, with rehab money paid out in draws as completed work is verified, inside the lender’s limit against ARV. It is a first-position, business-purpose loan for investment property, and your cash to close is the listed down payment, about $2,300 in closing costs and the appraisal.
Test one: will it appraise
The refinance depends on a new appraisal of the renovated house, based on comparable renovated sales nearby. In Melbourne that means choosing houses in areas with enough recent renovated sales of similar homes: a space-era block ranch in Eau Gallie compared with other updated ranches there, not with newer homes in Suntree or Viera. Buy where the comparables already prove the value you need.
The rehab has to show up in the appraisal. Appraisers credit new roofs, updated kitchens and baths, added bedrooms or bathrooms, and enclosed garages. They give less credit for expensive finishes that the neighborhood does not support. Many DSCR lenders also require a seasoning period of ownership before they will use the new value, so plan your timeline and reserves for that wait. Keep receipts and before-and-after photos of the work, since some appraisers and lenders find them useful when the improvements are not obvious from the street.
Test two: will it rent
Melbourne renters include aerospace and defense employees, hospital staff, airport workers, Florida Institute of Technology students and faculty, and military-connected households tied to Patrick Space Force Base. Most want reliable air conditioning, washer and dryer hookups, parking and a reasonable commute. A house that offers those things in a convenient location tends to lease without long vacancies.
Back the rent figure with evidence. Compare similar renovated houses that have actually leased, not only asking rents. A signed annual lease at a realistic rent is what the DSCR lender uses, so an aggressive estimate that never materializes can stall the refinance. Start marketing the house before the final punch list so a tenant is ready when the work is done.
Lease length matters for Melbourne in particular. Engineers on a new program often want a full year or more, while students follow the academic calendar and military families move on orders. Matching the lease term to the tenant group you are targeting keeps vacancies short and gives the refinance lender a lease that looks stable.
Test three: do the expenses fit
This is the test that sinks most Florida BRRRR plans. The DSCR lender divides rent by the full payment: principal, interest, property taxes, insurance and any association dues. Taxes on a rental are non-homestead and reset to your purchase price, then rise up to 10% a year. Insurance depends heavily on roof age, roof shape, openings and the wind mitigation report, and flood insurance adds another premium in mapped zones.
Lower expenses through the rehab itself. A new roof with proper straps and a secondary water barrier, impact windows, an updated panel and new plumbing all lower insurance or make the house insurable in the first place. Avoid houses in flood zones unless the numbers still work with flood insurance included. When two houses look similar on paper, the one on higher ground with a newer roof is usually the better BRRRR, even if its purchase price is a little higher.
- Get an insurance quote with the post-rehab roof and openings before you buy.
- Model taxes on the purchase price, not on the seller’s homestead bill.
- Check for HOA dues or district assessments in planned communities.
Repeating it carefully
When all three tests pass, the DSCR loan pays off the rehab loan and part or most of your cash comes back to you, depending on how well you bought. Use that cash for the next deal only after rebuilding reserves, because the next house will have its own surprises and the refinance clock does not care about them. Each finished BRRRR also strengthens your schedule of real estate owned, which future lenders will review on your next listing.
Stay in the parts of the Melbourne area you know best for the first few rounds. Knowing which streets flood, which have sewer, what renovated ranches appraise for and what tenants pay is worth more than any single good deal across the county. Track every deal against its original listing numbers too, so you learn whether your rehabs tend to run over and by how much.