BRRRR, defined for an Orlando investor
BRRRR is a five-step plan: buy a house below its after-repair value, rehab it, rent it, refinance into a long-term loan that returns much of your cash, and repeat. The refinance is the hinge. It only works if the finished house appraises well and the rent covers the long-term payment, and both depend on a purchase made at the right price.
In Orlando, the houses that fit best are 1950s-70s block ranches in neighborhoods with steady workforce rental demand, such as Pine Hills, Azalea Park, Conway and Washington Shores. They are durable, their rehab scopes are well understood, and their tenants come from employers that are not going anywhere. Newer subdivision homes can work too, if HOA rules allow leasing.
The workforce that rents these houses
Theme parks, hotels, restaurants, the convention center and the airport employ a very large hourly and salaried workforce, and many of those households rent single-family homes. Hospital systems add nurses, technicians and support staff working shifts at all hours. The University of Central Florida adds graduate students, staff and faculty on the east side. Commute matters to all of them, so houses near major roads like State Road 408, State Road 50 and the I-4 corridor tend to lease more easily.
Match the house to the commute. A Pine Hills ranch serves west-side workers heading to the parks and downtown. An Azalea Park or Conway house serves the airport, the east side and the hospitals. Price rent from comparable leases close to the house, not from a metro-wide figure.
Screening matters as much as location. Verify income and employment, check rental history, and set clear expectations about yard care, air filters and how to report repairs. A tenant who reports a slow drip under the sink in week one saves you a subfloor in month six. In BRRRR the first lease also becomes the rent history your refinance relies on, so a stable tenant is part of the financing plan, not just the operating plan.
Rehab with the loan already in place
Each Orlando listing on Think Off Market comes with a pre-approved Think Private Lending loan covering up to 90% of the purchase price plus 100% of the rehab budget, paid in draws as work is completed and verified, within the lender’s limit against the ARV. Because everything is sized off the after-repair value, the listing already tells you whether the finished value supports the plan.
A rental rehab should spend on systems and durability: roof, panel, drains, air conditioning, water heater and windows. Choose finishes that clean easily and repair cheaply. Avoid custom choices tenants will not pay for. Keep the scope tight so the draws move and the house reaches a lease quickly, since every vacant month costs interest and insurance with no rent coming in.
Think about the appraiser while you plan. The refinance appraisal will compare your house with renovated sales nearby, and an obviously dated bathroom or a missing appliance can pull the value down. Rental-grade does not mean unfinished. It means complete, clean and durable, with nothing that makes the house look like it stopped halfway.
- Priority one: anything that would fail a 4-point inspection.
- Priority two: air conditioning and water heater, the top sources of tenant calls in Central Florida.
- Priority three: durable flooring, paint and fixtures that survive several leases.
Refinance: how the DSCR loan sizes up
A DSCR loan is a long-term investment loan sized on the property’s rent. The lender divides the monthly rent by the full monthly payment, including principal, interest, property taxes, insurance and any HOA dues. A ratio comfortably above one shows the rent supports the debt. The appraisal of the finished, leased house sets the value the new loan is measured against.
Orlando investors should watch two things. First, property taxes reset at purchase because Florida’s 10% annual cap on non-homestead assessments does not carry over from the seller. Second, some east and north side subdivisions have HOA dues and leasing restrictions that affect both the ratio and whether you can rent at all. Read the covenants before you buy.
Repeat, with the first deal as your guide
The first Orlando BRRRR teaches you more than any projection, and the lessons are specific to your crew, your neighborhoods and your tenants. Record what the rehab actually cost, how long it took, how many days the house sat before leasing, what insurance and taxes really came to and how the appraisal compared with the listing’s ARV. Use those numbers on the next purchase. Keep reserves for a roof claim or a storm deductible, and keep your LLC documents and schedule of real estate owned up to date so the next file is ready.