Cap rate is a property’s annual net operating income divided by its price or value, a quick measure of its unleveraged yield as an income property.
Cap rate tells you what a property earns relative to its price if you paid all cash. Take the annual rent, subtract vacancy and operating expenses, and you have net operating income, or NOI. Divide NOI by the purchase price or current value. A house that nets $18,000 a year and costs $300,000 has a 6% cap rate. Loan payments are excluded, which is the point: cap rate measures the property, not the financing.
NOI is where honest numbers matter. Include property taxes, insurance, a vacancy allowance, repairs and maintenance, capital reserves for big items like the roof and HVAC, property management even if you self-manage, HOA dues, and any utilities you pay. Leave out mortgage principal and interest, depreciation and your own income taxes. Many sellers’ cap rates look high because they leave out management, reserves or vacancy. Rebuild the NOI yourself.
An example on a renovated single-family rental. Rent $2,300 a month, $27,600 a year. Vacancy at 5%, $1,380. Taxes $4,200, insurance $3,600, maintenance and reserves $2,800, management $2,500. NOI comes to about $13,120. If your all-in cost is $215,000, the cap rate on cost is about 6.1%. If the house would sell for $285,000 finished, the cap rate on value is about 4.6%. The gap between the two is the value the rehab created.
Florida cap rates are moved more by insurance and taxes than in many states. A roof replaced to current code with a wind mitigation report can lower insurance enough to move cap rate meaningfully. A purchase that resets the tax assessment raises taxes for the new owner. When you compare a Think Off Market listing as a rental, build NOI with your own insurance quote and a post-sale tax estimate, then compare cap rate on cost to the cap rates you see on finished rentals nearby.