Buying off market · 6 min read

Reading a listing the way the lender already did

Every Think Off Market listing carries six pieces of information: price, estimated ARV, a line-item rehab estimate, the approved loan, estimated cash to close and the borrower requirements. Read them in that order and you will know within minutes whether a house deserves a walk-through.

Start with the price, then ignore it for a minute

The price is what the seller will accept for the house in its current condition, as-is. It is the only number on the listing set by the seller rather than by underwriting. Note it, then set it aside, because on its own it tells you almost nothing. A $180,000 price is a great deal on one street and a terrible one three blocks over. The price only means something once you hold it up against what the house will be worth finished and what it will cost to get there.

One thing the price does tell you right away is your down payment. With financing at up to 90% of the purchase price, you bring at least 10% of the price at closing. A $180,000 house means at least $18,000 down before anything else, and that money has to be your own, sitting in an account you can document.

The ARV is the number everything else hangs on

The estimated after-repair value is what the house should sell for once the listed rehab is complete, based on recent comparable sales nearby. It is the most important number on the page because the loan is sized off it, your profit is measured against it, and a refinance appraisal will test it. The ARV on a listing is an estimate supported by comps, not an appraisal you have ordered.

Check it yourself. Pull sales from the last several months within a tight radius, same property type, similar size, similar age and similar finish level to what the rehab will deliver. If your comps land near the listing ARV, good. If you find yourself reaching for the one outlier sale on the best street, the number is probably high for your purposes.

Line items, not a lump sum

The rehab estimate is broken into line items, such as roof, electrical, plumbing, HVAC, kitchen, baths, flooring, paint, windows and exterior. That breakdown is far more useful than a single total, because it shows you exactly what scope the ARV assumes. If the comps that support the ARV have new kitchens and the line items include one, those two numbers agree. If the comps are fully renovated and the estimate is paint and carpet, they do not.

Read each line against what you see in the photos and later on the walk. A roof line in a Florida rehab is often the biggest single item and the one insurers care about most. A missing line for the electrical panel on a house that still has an old Federal Pacific or Zinsco panel is a red flag to raise before you sign.

Approved loan, cash to close and requirements

These three numbers tell you whether the deal works for you specifically, not just on paper. The approved loan is the amount Think Private Lending has approved for the property: up to 90% of the price plus 100% of the rehab, kept inside the lender’s limit against ARV. The rehab portion is held back and paid out in draws as work is completed and verified.

Estimated cash to close is what you need in the account at closing. It is roughly your down payment plus estimated closing costs, a flat estimate of about $2,300, plus the appraisal. It does not include reserves for carrying costs and surprises, and you should budget those separately. The borrower requirements list what you must bring to use the financing: usually an LLC to take title, credit in a reasonable range, liquidity and some experience or a licensed contractor.

  • Approved loan: the lender’s number on the house, already reviewed.
  • Cash to close: down payment plus about $2,300 in closing costs plus the appraisal.
  • Reserves: your number, sized to months of carrying costs plus a contingency.
  • Requirements: a checklist you either meet today or can meet before closing.

Three quick tests to run in your head

Once you have the numbers, three fast tests decide whether a house earns a walk-through. They take less time than reading the listing photos twice, and they catch most bad fits. None of them require software. A notepad, your comps and an honest look at your bank balance are enough to run all three in a few minutes.

  • Spread test: subtract price, rehab, closing costs, a realistic holding period and selling costs from ARV, and see whether what is left justifies the risk.
  • Cash test: add cash to close and at least several months of carrying costs, and confirm it sits comfortably inside your liquid funds.
  • Scope test: compare the line items to your contractor’s capacity and your experience, and pass on scopes you cannot manage well.

A sample listing, read out loud

Picture a 1970s concrete block ranch with a price of $210,000, an ARV of $330,000, and a $45,000 rehab with lines for roof, electrical panel, kitchen, two baths, flooring, paint and exterior. Ninety percent of price is $189,000. Add the full rehab and the loan is $234,000, provided that sits inside the lender’s ARV limit, which the approval already reflects. Down payment is $21,000. Cash to close is $21,000 plus about $2,300 plus the appraisal.

Now the judgment calls. The roof line tells you insurance should be easier to place after the work. The panel line tells you someone already spotted an old panel. The two-bath line matters because your comps likely have updated baths. If those comps support $330,000, the spread after holding and selling costs is worth a walk. If they top out lower, you adjust your offer or move on.

Red flags hiding in plain sight

Most bad deals announce themselves on the listing if you read slowly. An ARV that sits well above every renovated sale you can find is the loudest signal. A rehab budget with no roof line on a house whose photos show a patched, faded shingle roof is another. So is a scope that skips the panel, the water heater or the AC on a house old enough that all three are likely original.

Pay attention to what the photos avoid, too. A listing with ten kitchen shots and none of the back of the house, the ceilings or the electrical panel is telling you where to look first on the walk. None of these mean the deal is bad. They mean the numbers need your own check before your name goes on a contract.

What a listing cannot tell you

A listing is a strong starting point, but it cannot replace walking the house. Photos do not show the smell of a wet subfloor, the slope of a floor over a settling footer, the hum of an old AC compressor or what the neighbor’s yard looks like. Numbers do not tell you whether there is an open permit from a prior owner, a code lien, or an HOA with rental restrictions.

Once you are approved as a buyer, you see the full address, all the photos and access instructions. Use them. Walk the property with your contractor, compare what you see to each line item, and then sign the purchase contract with your eyes open. The pre-approved loan closes with Think Private Lending, and the draws fund the work you already planned.

Straight answers

Questions investors ask

Is the ARV on a listing the same as an appraisal?

No. The listing ARV is an estimate supported by comparable sales and reviewed by the lender. An appraisal is ordered as part of closing, and the estimated closing costs on a listing exclude the appraisal fee, which is added separately.

Does estimated cash to close include my reserves?

No. Cash to close covers the down payment, estimated closing costs of about $2,300 and the appraisal. Reserves for interest, insurance, taxes, utilities and surprises are separate, and the borrower requirements may set a minimum.

Can I change the rehab scope from what the listing shows?

You can propose changes after you walk the house. The approved loan is tied to the reviewed budget and the ARV it supports, so a different scope may change the loan amount. Raise it before you sign the purchase contract.

Why can I not see the full address right away?

Full addresses, complete photos and access instructions are shown to approved buyers. Requesting access is free, and approval keeps sellers’ properties in front of investors who can actually perform.

See the addresses. Walk the houses. Close with the money already lined up.

Buyer access is free. Tell us what you buy and where, and we will open the full listings: addresses, photos, access instructions and the financing terms behind each one.