The rule in one line
Maximum purchase price equals ARV times 0.70, minus the rehab budget. On a house with a $300,000 ARV and a $50,000 rehab, the rule says pay no more than $160,000: $210,000 minus $50,000. The 30% gap is supposed to cover closing costs on both ends, holding costs, selling costs, mistakes and profit. That is a lot to ask of one number.
The rule became popular because it is easy to do in your head while standing in a driveway. That is its real value. It is a first filter that knocks out deals that are obviously too tight, so you spend your time on the ones that might work. Where investors get hurt is using it as the final answer instead of the first question.
Where the 30 percent actually goes
To see why the rule bends, break that 30% into its parts. On a typical flip, the gap between ARV and all-in cost has to absorb buy-side closing costs, interest and points, property taxes, insurance, utilities, lawn and pool care, any HOA dues, listing commissions, seller concessions and title costs on the sale, and then whatever is left over as profit.
Some of those costs scale with price, like commissions. Some do not, like the flat closing cost estimate of about $2,300 on a loan, the appraisal fee or a basic insurance policy. And some scale with time, like interest and utilities. A rule that treats them all as a fixed percentage of ARV will be wrong whenever price or timeline moves away from the middle.
Insurance can eat the margin
Insurance is the first Florida-specific crack in the rule. A vacant house under renovation needs coverage, and the cost of that coverage depends heavily on roof age, construction type, location relative to the coast and flood zone. Many carriers will not write older roofs at all, which can push a rehab into more expensive specialty coverage, or in some cases Citizens Property Insurance, the state-created insurer of last resort.
The rule has no line for that. Two houses with the same ARV and rehab budget can carry very different insurance costs because one has a newer roof and the other is a 1980s frame house near the water in a high-risk flood zone. Get an insurance quote during your inspection period and put the real number in your math.
Taxes and time do not care about the rule
Florida property taxes are the second crack. When you buy, the assessed value of a non-homestead property resets toward market value for the next tax year, and the seller’s capped assessment does not follow you. If you buy from a long-time homesteaded owner, the bill you inherit may look small while the bill your buyer or your rental inherits looks much larger. On a flip, prorated taxes at sale are a real cost the rule ignores.
Time is the third. The rule assumes an average hold. Permitting backlogs after storms, roof material lead times, insurance delays and a slow listing period each add months. Every extra month means more interest, utilities, insurance and lawn care. A deal that works at five months may not work at nine.
How price point bends the rule
Price point exposes the rule fastest, and the effect runs in both directions depending on which side of the middle you are on. The same fixed percentage produces a thin dollar profit on a cheap house and a fat cushion on an expensive one, which is backwards from how most of the costs actually behave.
- On low-priced houses, fixed costs like closing fees, appraisals, insurance minimums and permit fees are a larger share of ARV, so 70% can leave too little profit.
- On higher-priced houses, the 30% gap becomes a large dollar figure, so strict 70% offers may lose every deal to buyers who correctly need less margin.
- On houses with long rehabs, carrying costs pile up, so the rule needs a lower multiplier.
- On quick cosmetic flips with new roofs and systems, carrying costs shrink, and a higher multiplier can still leave a healthy profit.
Replace the rule with a real deal sheet
The better approach is a simple sheet that lists each cost in dollars rather than as a percentage. Start with ARV. Subtract selling costs. Subtract the rehab budget including contingency. Subtract buy-side closing costs. Subtract holding costs: monthly interest, taxes, insurance, utilities, lawn, pool and HOA multiplied by a realistic number of months. Then subtract the profit you require. What is left is your maximum price.
That sheet takes ten minutes and answers the question the 70% rule only approximates. It also makes negotiation easier, because you can show a seller exactly why your number is your number. On Think Off Market listings, the ARV, line-item rehab and estimated cash to close give you the top half of that sheet already filled in.
Two houses, same rule, different answers
Consider two flips that both pass the 70% rule exactly. The first is a 1990s block home inland with a newer roof, a light cosmetic scope and no HOA. It closes, gets painted, floored and listed within a few months, and insurance is ordinary. The second is a 1970s frame home in a coastal flood zone with an old roof, an original panel and a full interior. Same multiplier, same ARV math on paper.
The second house will almost certainly carry higher insurance, a longer permit timeline, a bigger contingency and a longer listing period, because fewer buyers want an older frame house in a flood zone. The rule says both deals are equal. A deal sheet would show the second one needs a meaningfully lower price to earn the same profit.
Using financing terms in the math
Leverage changes how much cash a deal ties up, not how much profit it makes, and the rule treats both as the same. With financing at up to 90% of purchase price plus 100% of rehab, paid in draws and kept inside the lender’s ARV limit, your cash in the deal is mostly the down payment, closing costs and carrying costs. That is efficient, but interest on the loan becomes a real line on your sheet.
Put the loan amount, rate and expected months in your numbers and calculate interest in dollars. Ask how interest is charged on undrawn rehab funds. Then decide whether the profit justifies the cash and the risk. That is a question no rule of thumb can answer for you.